When I first saw this on the New York Times website:
Records Say Chinese Gymnasts May Be Under Age
I just about had an aneurysm. A big old, full-blown aneurysm. Because my brain was about to explode from the fact that the New York Times had picked up on this story. The shock isn’t that the Chinese had broken the age rules–because frankly everyone in the gymnastics community has known this for months, and even when it came out I don’t anyone was honestly shocked to the core. No, I was shocked that a major (and I mean major) news outlet was picking up the story. Today, the story has spread like wildfire. It’s everywhere. Just Google it. ABC News, Yahoo. It’s everywhere.
Now, I have a few quick points to make before I go on and give my own two cents on this entire debacle. Officially, He Kexin and Jiang Yuyuan are of age. Their passports say that they are old enough to compete in the Olympics. Therefore, as far as the IOC, FIG, and all official matters are concerned, they are of age. Second, the rules say that a gymnast must turn 16 in the calendar year to be eligible as a senior, ie for the Olympic Games. Thirdly, there is absolutely no way to prove one way or the other what age these girls are.
So what do I think? Let ME tell YOU.
These girls are too young. It’s not fair to the other gymnasts, and though nothing really can be done to change it because of the reasons stated above, it will forever taint any and all medals that China wins. Two gymnasts are almost certainly under age, but there’s pretty strong suspicion about the others. In fact, only one gymnast–Cheng Fei–is absolutely age eligible. We only know that because she competed in the Olympics four years ago when she was, almost certainly, under age. If China wins the team gold, I will be royally peeved that the US–which has followed this rule–were beaten out by cheaters. If He Kexin beats out Nastia for the gold on bars, I will be royally peeved, also that Nastia lost out. Four years ago, Nastia was good enough to win a medal at the Olympics, but she couldn’t go because she was a year too young. Now He is a year too young, but she gets to go to the Olympics and possibly beat out Nastia, who played by the rules and had to stick around for four very long years. That stinks of unfairness.
And oh, yes, it is cheating of the highest degree. There appears to be some sentiment going around the gymnastics boards (hey, I have a lot of free time at work, so sue me), that it’s okay for the Chinese to break the rule because it’s a bad rule. This ain’t apartheid, folks. I don’t agree with the age limit. I mean, swimming doesn’t have an age limit, and swimmers don’t normally peak at 14-16 years of age. Gymnastics does have an age limit that excludes girls under 16, when the peak for gymnasts is often 14-16. Why is this rule in place if it excludes so many girls who are in the very brief prime of their abilities? It’s purely PR. Image.
It’s a sucky rule as far as I’m concerned. BUT (and it’s a big, huge but), that doesn’t mean it can be broken. It’s not a matter of injustice. It’s a matter of a bad rule, but it’s bad for everyone, if only everyone follows it. It isn’t fair that some people lose out while others don’t. Everyone has to play by the same rules, or it’s CHEATING. Faking ages gives a huge, huge advantage. It gives China a wider range of gymnasts to choose from. As I mentioned, many athletes reach their peak at this younger age, so not only is it a wider selection it’s an arguably better selection, too. They have a distinct advantage, an advantage just as great if not greater than doping. So for those who seem to think that it is alright to break a bad rule, or that it doesn’t matter much, I’m afraid I totally and utterly disagree.
Some people almost seem to suggest that this age falsification is acceptable because it’s happened it the past, that the Americans are showing sour grapes. Come on. Just because Soviets and Romanians and Koreans falsified ages in the past, that hardly makes it okay now. Some have said that Americans are being hypocritical because of all the athletes caught doping. That’s entirely irrelevant. Because athletes in another sport have doped, that has no bearing on the validity of American calling out the Chinese for cheating.
This isn’t about sour grapes, either. This is about exposing the rampant cheating. It’s happening now for several reasons. The Chinese are favored to win, and the favorites are always scrutinized more. In the past, China was a contender but never so heavily favored, so the scrutiny wasn’t there. Also, evidence exists now that even four years ago couldn’t be dug up. There are documents and articles that give evidence of the gymnasts’ age, types of evidence that exist now that China is more in the information age. Shifting focus and blame from the Chinese to Americans who call them out for cheating is simply a diversionary tactic. It doesn’t mean that the Chinese aren’t cheating.
Now, there is one argument that I consider very legitimate. And that is this: there’s no proof. There is no solid evidence. We can speculate til we’re blue in the face, but that’s it. Now, we pretty much all know the truth, but basically the Chinese are laughing because they can get away with it. Or maybe they’re just as alarmed as we are. They bungled their age falsifying a little, but didn’t expect anything to happen, or were smug enough to believe that nothing could be proven or done about it. It could be that they’re shocked their mistakes came back to bite them. But not hard, because they were right; no one can do anything about it.
Now, to flip the coin a bit. No one can blame these girls. There has been a slight undercurrent of anger towards the gymnasts. Some online posters want the Chinese to fall on their faces because they’re too young. Others have veiled implications that they blame the gymnasts themselves. Let’s get real. It’s not the gymnasts who are to blame. What are they supposed to do? Tell the national team coach, their family, the Chinese government, that no, I won’t allow you to falsify my age! I am going to insist upon waiting four more years before I can compete in the Olympics. Of course not. It’s officials and coaches who are to blame. So everyone has to keep away from these girls.
My hope is that this publicity will continue to grow and grow. Yes, another gymnastics controversy, this one before the games even begin! But the publicity is absolutely necessary. It will bring attention to something that has been rampant in the sport ever since age restrictions were put in place. Maybe it will be enough to make people realize how damaging the age restrictions are and that the FIG is short-sighted and is damaging the sport. Who knows what will come of this. My hope is that everyone will know and remember that the Chinese won whatever medals they win through cheating. And I hope it brings changes to the FIG, and maybe a lowering of the age limit.
We’ll see. Stay tuned.
PS. I’m terribly bummed to hear that Paul Hamm is out of the Olympics. How terrible! I was really looking forward to seeing him compete!